Governor Signs Landmark Innocence Protection Law Against Unreliable Jailhouse Informants
Oklahoma becomes third in the nation to require statewide tracking of jailhouse informants.
05.21.20 By Innocence Staff
(Oklahoma City, OK – May 21, 2020) Governor Kevin Stitt signed a new law cracking down on unreliable jailhouse informants— incarcerated witnesses who testify in exchange for leniency in their own cases. Four wrongful convictions in Oklahoma involved false jailhouse informant testimony, including Ron Williamson and Dennis Fritz, whose cases were featured in John Grisham’s book and documentary “The Innocent Man.”
The new law, sponsored by Senator Julie Daniels (R-Bartlesville) and Representative Chris Kannady (R-South Oklahoma City), will make Oklahoma the third state in the country to establish statewide tracking of jailhouse informants (Senate Bill 1385). Maryland enacted a similar measure last month and Connecticut last year.
“In the past two years Oklahoma has tackled the leading causes of wrongful conviction–unreliable jailhouse informants, eyewitness identification and false confessions,” said Senator Daniels. “I’m proud that our state is creating a more fair and accurate justice system.”
“Oklahoma is taking another major step in preventing wrongful convictions,” said Rep. Kannady. “Addressing unreliable jailhouse informants, in addition passing eyewitness identification and recording suspect interrogations reforms last year, will protect the innocent and improve public safety.”
“Lifting the secrecy around incentivized testimony will protect innocent Oklahomans and victims of jailhouse informants’ crimes. Thanks to the leadership of Senator Daniels and Representative Kannady, this law promotes transparency to reveal the truth and prevent wrongful convictions.” said Vicki Behenna, Executive Director of the Oklahoma Innocence Project.
Ron Williamson was wrongfully sentenced to death and Dennis Fritz to life in prison for the 1982 rape and murder of Debbie Sue Carter in Ada, Oklahoma. Carter’s cousin Christy Sheppard said: “Two innocent men and my family were devastated by unreliable jailhouse witnesses. The new law can protect the next innocent man and deliver the justice that crime victims deserve.”
While Williamson was in jail for writing bad checks, another inmate claimed she heard him confess to the murder. The same jailhouse informant had been used multiple times to secure convictions and received substantial benefits that were never disclosed to the defense. Fritz was implicated in the crime, and while awaiting trial, his cellmate claimed to hear him confess. Seventeen years later DNA evidence proved that Williamson and Fritz were innocent and that man named Glenn Gore–who went on to commit other crimes–was the actual culprit.
The new law protects against false jailhouse informant testimony by:
- Requiring district attorneys’ offices to centrally track each case in which a jailhouse informant testifies and the benefits provided.
- Creating a statewide record where district attorneys will report this information, which will be maintained by the Oklahoma District Attorneys Council (DAC). DAC will issue an annual report on the aggregate data tracked in the system.
- Specifies that prosecutors must disclose specific jailhouse witness information to the defense before trial, including: deals or benefits provided for testimony, their complete criminal history, and previous incentivized testimony given in other cases.
Leave a Reply
Thank you for visiting us. You can learn more about how we consider cases here. Please avoid sharing any personal information in the comments below and join us in making this a hate-speech free and safe space for everyone.
May 27, 2020 at 2:52 am
I am Confident that this is a Great Change and that The Innocent and their Families can find peace and that the Reliability of a Statement for a Crime is WITHOUT DOUBT 100% A FACT not A Reward. Our System can be Restored for the Good and This is a Great Start.
Raymond Grimsbo PhD, F-AAFS (ret) June 1, 2020 at 8:24 pm
Having practiced forensic science for the last 44+ years, I have witnessed the use of unreliable jailhouse informants and witnesses. In most cases the physical evidence does not support their statements, especially when DNA is not present.