Compensating the Wrongly Convicted in Hawaii


About half of people exonerated by DNA have not been compensated for the injustice they suffered and the time they spent incarcerated.

An editorial in Wednesday’s Honolulu Star Advertiser said Hawaii should join the list of states that compensates its wrongfully convicted once they are released from prison.

In the wake of Hawaii’s recent release of Alvin Jardine, who spent 20 years in prison for crimes DNA evidence now suggests he did not commit, University of Hawaii Sociology Professor David T. Johnson said criminal justice officials routinely ignore the serious errors in the system.

Hawaii law makes no promises to victims like Alvin Jardine: no financial compensation, no services, no assistance of any kind. The most he can currently hope for is an apology from the officials who made the mistake that stole 7,000 days of his life. But “Oops, sorry!” is not enough, and suing is unlikely to gain him anything because the U.S. Supreme Court has made it all but impossible to recover damages from the people responsible for miscarriages of justice.

Hawaii’s law needs to be changed. So does the tendency of criminal justice officials to deny the reality of ruinous mistakes about guilt and innocence — sometimes in the absence of malice, and sometimes in its presence.

Jardine, who was granted a new trial after his conviction was overturned in January, maintained his innocence throughout his trials, claiming that he was at home at the time of the attack. He gave up the possibility of parole a decade earlier by refusing to enter sex-abuse treatment that would have required him to admit guilt,

according to the Star Advertiser.

Read the full editorial.

27 States Have Compensation Statutes:

Is Yours One?

Leave a Reply

Thank you for visiting us. You can learn more about how we consider cases here. Please avoid sharing any personal information in the comments below and join us in making this a hate-speech free and safe space for everyone.

This field is required.
This field is required.
This field is required.

Peter Tai September 25, 2019 at 4:18 pm Reply   

What’s wrongfully accused and arrested for armed robbery Empire arms and under arrested c r u crime reduction unit keep Rollin in my garage when I was living in Waianae Hawaii pick me up not a word said was left wondering what the heck is going on 3 days didn’t get to speak to anyone maybe a week indicted charged and off to prison my life went out the door….. one year later the state did the trial I stood before the identifying Witness and 12 people that was n Jury then out of the blue I get an email Stadium congratulations it’s all done you are Miss identified a computer have any questions call me misdemeanor no let me send I was not gone for 232 weeks I was gone for a year very well-known I’m going to cheever I get all that match Eve stuff I work for myself Renee got released I went back to my job and I was working at the door closed a lot of doors closed for me I have no life nobody wanted to be involved or even talk to me.. I once had big opportunities that laid in front of me..i also had a house unfortunately I’m in a emergency shelter now because of the situation Im now also suffering from anxiety paranoia and bipolar…Aloha

We've helped free more than 240 innocent people from prison. Support our work to strengthen and advance the innocence movement.