12th Dallas County Man in Five Years Is Proven Innocent Through DNA Evidence


James Waller Appears in Court Jan. 17th

(DALLAS, TX; January 16, 2007) – At a court hearing tomorrow, the Dallas County District Attorney's Office and the Innocence Project will file papers showing that James Waller did not commit the rape of a child he was convicted of in 1983. Waller, who has been on parole for several years and will appear in court today, is the twelfth Dallas County man in five years who has been proven innocent through DNA testing – the latest in what the Innocence Project said is an "alarming and completely unprecedented" pattern of wrongful convictions in one county.

Wednesday's hearing will be in front of Judge John Creuzot in Criminal District Court Number Four on the sixth floor of the Frank Crowley Courts Building (133 N. Industrial Blvd.) in Dallas. The hearing will begin at 11:30 a.m. Waller and his attorneys – Barry Scheck and Nina Morrison of the Innocence Project, with Jeff Blackburn of the Innocence Project of Texas and Houston attorney Randy Schaffer, who worked on Waller's case in his earlier attempts to secure DNA testing – will speak to reporters after the hearing. Several of Waller's relatives from around the country have traveled to Dallas to attend the hearing, and several of the other 11 Dallas County men who have been proven innocent through DNA testing will attend the hearing, as well.

"I've been trying to get DNA testing for years. It's been a long, horrible road. This is one of the happiest weeks of my life – I am finally having my day in court, and I will be able to clear my name at long last," Waller said. Waller first sought DNA testing in 1989. Shortly before his first court hearing seeking testing, in 2001, he and his pregnant wife were in a car accident on the way to the airport to meet relatives who were traveling to the hearing; Waller's wife died in the accident, and their fetus did not survive.

In 1983 – after a trial lasting only several hours, and jury deliberations lasting 46 minutes – Waller was convicted of aggravated sexual abuse in connection with the rape of a 12-year-old boy, and he was sentenced to 30 years in prison. Waller was released on parole in 1993, and has spent the last 13 years living under strict parole conditions as a registered sex offender. In 1989, he began seeking DNA testing to prove his innocence; in 2001, when the State Legislature passed a law granting post-conviction access to DNA testing, he redoubled his efforts. The state refused to allow the testing to be conducted at a private DNA lab, and a state lab was unable to obtain a sufficient DNA profile when it conducted tests. In 2004, the Innocence Project helped secure a previously unavailable type of DNA testing (on liquid extracts of the evidence, since the evidence was consumed during the inconclusive tests by the state lab), and the results show that Waller is innocent.

Waller was convicted based largely on the 12-year-old victim's identification of him – an identification that the Innocence Project said should have raised serious concerns among law enforcement agencies at the time. The day after he was sexually assaulted, the boy was in a 7-Eleven convenience store near his apartment complex, and heard a voice behind him that sounded like the perpetrator's. When he turned and saw Waller, he became further convinced that he was the perpetrator – even though the victim had earlier told police that he never saw his attacker face-to-face. The sexual assault happened at 6 a.m., when an African-American man entered an apartment occupied by the 12-year-old boy and his younger brother (their mother and other relatives had already left for work) and ordered the victim to lie face down on a pillow. He then orally and anally sodomized the child and left the apartment. The victim told police that his attacker wore a bandana covering most of his face. Waller and his family lived in the same apartment complex, and they were in the only African-American residents of the complex. Waller was substantially taller and heavier than the victim's initial description of the perpetrator.

"Rather than questioning a traumatized boy's memory or using simple procedures to evaluate how certain he was of the identification, police arrested James Waller and built a case around convicting him. They turned a scared child's mistake into a miscarriage of justice," said Barry Scheck, Co-Director of the Innocence Project, which is affiliated with Cardozo School of Law at Yeshiva University. "Most of the 12 wrongful convictions in Dallas County that have recently been uncovered through DNA testing involved eyewitness misidentification. Nobody can credibly deny that there is an alarming pattern in Dallas County, or that we need a statewide mechanism to identify and address the causes of wrongful convictions."

Texas State Senator Rodney Ellis plans to introduce legislation this week to create a state Innocence Commission. This bill,

which was also introduced in the last legislative session

, would create an expert panel from across the state's criminal justice community to examine wrongful convictions in Texas, learn what caused them and recommend steps the state can take to prevent them in the future.

Since 2001,

12 Dallas County men

have been proven innocent through DNA testing – a pattern that the Innocence Project said is both unprecedented and troubling. "Nowhere else in the nation have so many individual wrongful convictions b een proven in one county in such a short span of time. This demands closer look and statewide action," Scheck said. Just as in Waller's case, most of the cases involved sexual assault, and most of the men were convicted in the mid-1980s.

Eight years after he was released on parole, Waller began a lengthy legal struggle seeking DNA testing – at his own expense. "James Waller has been out of prison since 1993, but he has not been free," Morrison said. "The conditions of his parole, the requirements of the convicted sex offender registry, and the stain of being convicted of such a heinous crime have taken an enormous toll. Even when he volunteers serving food to homeless people through his church group, James is not allowed to interact with children. When a homeless child comes through the line, James has to ask someone else to serve the food, since he is a registered sex offender and cannot have contact with kids."

At Wednesday's hearing, the DA and the Innocence Project will enter findings of Waller's innocence into the record and will file a writ with the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals to vacate Waller's conviction.

Not including Waller (who will need an order from the Court of Criminal Appeals or a pardon from Texas's governor), 190 people in 32 states have been exonerated through DNA testing. The Innocence Project, affiliated with Cardozo School of Law, has provided direct representation or consultation in most of them. The Innocence Project of Texas is handling a number of other cases throughout the state in which people are seeking DNA testing to prove their innocence.

Leave a Reply

Thank you for visiting us. You can learn more about how we consider cases here. Please avoid sharing any personal information in the comments below and join us in making this a hate-speech free and safe space for everyone.

This field is required.
This field is required.
This field is required.