4 Exonerees on How Their Dogs Changed Their Lives

“I always told her ... one day we will be free.”

08.26.20 By Daniele Selby

Malcolm Alexander and Inn are reunited on Jan. 31, 2018, one day after his exoneration. (Image: Courtesy of Malcolm Alexander)

Malcolm Alexander and Inn are reunited on Jan. 31, 2018, one day after his exoneration. (Image: Courtesy of Malcolm Alexander)

“They say a dog is a man’s best friend, and Inn really is my best friend,” exoneree Malcolm Alexander told the Innocence Project of his dog Inn — short for Innocence.

Today, on International Dog Day, we’re highlighting exonerees’ stories about their canine companions and how they’ve helped them navigate a new world and rebuild their lives as free people.

Malcolm Alexander and Inn’s first Mardi Gras together. (Image: Courtesy of Malcolm Alexander)

Malcolm Alexander

Alexander’s bond with Inn is unlike that of most owners and their dogs because they “came through the fire together,” the 60-year-old said. 

Inn was born in the Louisiana State Penitentiary — also known as Angola prison — where Alexander was serving a life sentence, without the possibility of parole, for a crime he didn’t commit.

Inn’s mother was a friend’s dog, a companion that incarcerated people are sometimes allowed to keep, who’d had a litter. Inn was the runt and the only one among the black lab puppies that had a white paw. She immediately caught Alexander’s attention, and at a friend’s suggestion, he named her Innocence as a reminder of his fight for justice.

For nine months Alexander raised the puppy behind bars. At work, during the day, she was always by his side, but at night, when he would return to the dormitory, Inn had to stay behind.

“I made her a place to sleep at work since she couldn’t come back to the dormitory with me, except on weekends sometimes,” Alexander said.

“I always told her when she was growing up in there that one day we will be free … I knew it was just a matter of time.”

Alexander was exonerated and freed on Jan. 30, 2018. The next day, he and Inn were reunited — both free — Alexander for the first time in 38 years and Inn for the first time in her life. And they’ve been inseparable since.

“I can’t move without her. I keep her with me always,” he said. Alexander takes Inn fishing, and he and his wife Brenda take Inn on all their outings and trips. Inn has even become a local celebrity, leading the Barkus parade — the annual Mardi Gras dog parade — in New Orleans twice as the “Princess Royale.”

But Alexander isn’t the only exoneree who’s canine companion has provided hope and support through the challenges of building a new life.

Chester Hollman and Journey. (Image: Courtesy of Chester Hollman III)

Chester Hollman III and Journey

“Journey has been my guiding light, so to speak,” Chester Hollman III told the Innocence Project. Hollman, who is featured in the Netflix documentary series “The Innocence Files,” was exonerated last year after spending 28 years in prison for a crime he didn’t commit. He was represented by the Pennsylvania Innocence Project

Hollman had first spotted Journey as a 6-month-old puppy in the dog training program at Retreat State Correctional Institution in Pennsylvania. Journey — or Buttons as she was named then — was one of several dogs from the SPCA that was sent to the prison where incarcerated people would train them and prepare them for adoption.

Though Hollman wasn’t part of the program, he saw the dogs daily at his job in the gym where the dogs would do some of their training. Typically, only prison staff were allowed to adopt dogs from the programs — not incarcerated people — but because Hollman was hoping to be exonerated soon, his supervisor, who was also the prison’s liaison to the SPCA, suggested he adopt one of the dogs if he was freed.

“Journey always stood out ever since her arrival [to the program]. She was so small but yet so rambunctious and not afraid of the bigger dogs,” Hollman remembered. “I began to try and visualize her as my own in the outside world if given the chance.”

Chester Hollman and Journey. (Image: Courtesy of Chester Hollman III)

On July 30, 2019, Hollman walked free. Paperwork and logistical challenges kept Journey from joining him that day, but the very next morning, Hollman and his family made the 2.5 hour drive to pick her up. Once home and free, Hollman decided to change her name from Buttons to Journey.

“I just couldn’t see myself calling anything buttons in this life that wasn’t attached to a shirt … and Journey just seemed so fitting for what we had both just come through, and a journey it has been,” he said.

“I didn’t know how I would adjust to life after so many years away and care for a dog, but truthfully, it’s the one of best decisions I’ve ever made. We’ve come a long way together since having been set free. She’s added a different kind of balance to my life that I’m just so grateful to have because of her.” 

Hollman said he can’t wait to grow old with her.

Clemente Aguirre-Jarquin and Puko. (Image: Courtesy of Clemente Aguirre-Jarquin)

Clemente Aguirre-Jarquin and Puko

Clemente Aguirre-Jarquin, who was also exonerated in 2018, after 12 years of wrongful conviction, said his dog Puko is his rock and helps him whenever he feels “stuck”.

“I can’t really explain it, but he’s my everything,” Aguirre-Jarquin told the Innocence Project. “He gives unconditional love. There’s no judgement, it’s not about money … He just loves you and how much love you give to him.”

He adopted Puko — a Mayan word meaning “freedom” — when he was just 2 weeks old from a litter of abandoned puppies. From the moment he saw Puko, Aguirre-Jarquin said the pitbull puppy stole his heart, but it wasn’t until the pup became sick that he realized how much he’d come to depend on Puko.

“All I could think was ‘What am I supposed to do without my baby boy?’” he recalled. Puko made a full recovery, and has returned to his energetic and playful self.

(Left) Puko as a puppy. (Right) Clemente Aguirre-Jarquin and Puko at the beach. (Images: Courtesy of Clemente Aguirre-Jarquin)

Belynda Goff and Marley. (Image: Courtesy of Belynda Goff)

Belynda Goff and Marley, Samsonite, and Rooster

Belynda Goff spent her entire life around dogs before being wrongfully convicted. And even while wrongfully incarcerated, she continued to work with dogs as one of the first incarcerated women to participate in the “Paws in Prison” program at the Hawkins Women’s Unit in Arkansas.

As part of the program, Goff worked with approximately 19 dogs rescued from kill shelters, training and readying them for their new homes, including preparing some to become service dogs.

“I absolutely loved being a part of the program! They should be in every prison. Most staff and inmates were happy to have the interaction with dogs on a regular basis: it improved the morale of most. And of course saved the life of the animals,” she told the Innocence Project.

Now  free after 23 years of wrongful incarceration, she said she feels “deeply blessed” by her “precious fur balls” Marley, Samsonite, and Rooster.

Whether I’ve loved dogs through fostering, training, or ownership they are truly a special gift from God,” she said.

(Left) Belynda Goff and Samsonite. (Right) Belynda and Rooster. (Images: Courtesy of Belynda Goff)

Leave a Reply

Thank you for visiting us. You can learn more about how we consider cases here. Please avoid sharing any personal information in the comments below and join us in making this a hate-speech free and safe space for everyone.

This field is required.
This field is required.
This field is required.

Penni Boehme August 28, 2020 at 10:26 pm Reply   

Wow,unbelievable…Great job,need to expand that program that Arkansas has and to male Prisoners as well…I found the story about the inmate who had to WATCH particularly heartbreaking that they can’t adopt..Even Though Thank God for Your Work Innocence Project because that story turned out happy..Thousands sit in prison NOT guilty of other crimes,I wish You guys could expand your work after so many years..Somebody step up to the plate..corruption is rampant in law enforcement! Blessings to All!

Karen Scherrer August 28, 2020 at 2:08 pm Reply   

Unbelievable work. Thank God for you guys.

See More

We've helped free more than 240 innocent people from prison. Support our work to strengthen and advance the innocence movement.