Michigan Arson Conviction Vacated After Five Years


After five years in prison for a 2009 arson conviction, a Michigan man walked out of the Cadillac courthouse a free man on Tuesday, reported

Cadillac News



Victor Caminata was sharing a home with his then-girlfriend in Wexford County in March 2008 when a fire destroyed it. Although initially saying the cause of the fire was the chimney, fire investigators later claimed that char marks pointed to arson, and his girlfriend provided a possible motive when she said they were going to break up.


About a year ago, Director of the

Michigan Innocence Clinic

, Dave Moran, and his co-counsel filed a motion for relief based on the conclusion that the state’s arson experts had committed fundamental errors in violation of National Fire Protection Agency 921 (NFPA 921). Defense experts believe that the supposed signs of arson were spurious and that the original determination that an accidental chimney fire had burned down the house was correct. NFPA 921 adopts the scientific method for fire investigations and explicitly debunks the so-called “indicators” of arson that were routinely used by fire investigators for decades but are not rooted in science. It was first published in January 1992 and has been updated several times since then, but not all fire investigators use it routinely.


A Wexford County judge vacated Caminata’s conviction based on this evidence and ordered him released on personal recognizance bond. Although the Attorney General has 30 days to decide whether or not to pursue a retrial, Caminata is already spending time with his family. He was reunited with his three children and plans to live with his sister until he finds a place of his own.

“Nothing can make up for that lost time,” Caminata said. “All I can do is look to the future.”

In related news,

Northern California Innocence Project

client George Souliotes, whose conviction for arson murder was overturned in April, was also set to be released on Tuesday in Modesto, California, after 16 years in prison. Souliotes, who is 72 years old and in failing health, entered a plea of no-contest to involuntary manslaughter in order to be reunited with his family. As of this writing, his release has been temporarily delayed by state prison officials.


Read the

full article



Read more

about the Souliotes case


Leave a Reply

Thank you for visiting us. You can learn more about how we consider cases here. Please avoid sharing any personal information in the comments below and join us in making this a hate-speech free and safe space for everyone.

This field is required.
This field is required.
This field is required.

Mona fawaz June 18, 2017 at 9:42 pm Reply   

Saddly Im suffering with the same problem it been since 2009

We've helped free more than 240 innocent people from prison. Support our work to strengthen and advance the innocence movement.