Happy one year exoneration anniversary, Everton and Reginald!

07.27.16 By Kavish Harjai

Happy one year exoneration anniversary, Everton and Reginald!

One year ago today, Everton Wagstaffe and Reginald Connor were exonerated when a Brooklyn appeals court ruled that they had been wrongfully convicted in 1993 after a 16-year-old girl in Brooklyn, New York, was kidnapped and found dead on New Year’s Day 1992.  

Everton and Reginald were convicted based on the testimony of an informant who said that she’d witnessed the two men grab the female victim and force her into a car.  

The Innocence Project consulted on the case and aided in testing foreign hairs found on the victim’s body, which excluded both Everton and Reginald of the crime. Additionally, it was revealed that prosecutors had buried exculpatory evidence in the case. Based on this and other new evidence, Everton was released from prison on September 23, 2014. Connor had been earlier released on parole in 2004. Both men were fully exonerated on July 27, 2015.

Everton on cell

Photo by Sameer Abdel-Khalek

In recognition of Everton and Reginald’s one year exoneration anniversary, we caught up with Everton to see what his life is like post-exoneration.

Now, Everton is in Florida volunteering for Habitat for Humanity, building houses for low-income families. This experience has provided him with some gratitude but is also a way for him to cultivate new skills.

“It’s a learning experience,” he said. “It’s like a vocational school. I get something from what I give.”

Everton is also in the process of pursuing a full-time job.

Something that shocked Everton during his readjustment process was how rapidly technology developed. However, technology is just a small part of his readjustment process.

“You have to slowly learn the things that you were deprived of for 23 years,” Everton explained.

Everton also finds that it’s hard to speak about his experiences with people who haven’t had similar experiences. To deal with that, Everton said he had to “learn how to cope, just like [he] did when [he] was in prison.” The process has been psychologically challenging for Everton.

“I’ve tried to move on but you can’t just move on from 23 years of deprivation,” Everton said. “It’s psychological and I can’t just dismiss it from my life.”

Everton Smiling

Photo by Sameer Abdel-Khalek

While the readjustment process is challenging, Everton is confident in himself; he knows he “has the capability to do everything he wants to do.” Something that has been particularly liberating after being freed from prison is something that many of us take for granted: the ability to move around freely. Everton says his newfound freedom of mobility starkly contrasts with his life in prison, where every move he made was inhibited.

“I get the chance to go wherever I can go because I can just go,” he explained. “It’s very exhilarating to be able to move wherever you want to move.”

Congratulations on your one year exoneration anniversary, Everton and Reginald!

Leave a Reply

Thank you for visiting us. You can learn more about how we consider cases here. Please avoid sharing any personal information in the comments below and join us in making this a hate-speech free and safe space for everyone.

This field is required.
This field is required.
This field is required.

John Hyson August 19, 2016 at 3:31 pm Reply   

There is no check big enough to cover having 23 years of your life taken from your hands.

Irene Chiddenton August 17, 2016 at 4:21 pm Reply   

Take your time young man I know that it has been difficult – but you will find that the adjustment period may be a little longer than you would like – I am so glad you were exonerated for sure – time heals all things – my grandfather used to say and believe me the older I get the more I realize it is so true. Also he also said the there is such a thing as Karma and you don’t need to fret over “payback”. I hope you find peace and most of all happiness in life from now on. I will remember your story and pray for you always. Take good care

See More

We've helped free more than 240 innocent people from prison. Support our work to strengthen and advance the innocence movement.